Skip to content

I Witness by Niki Mackay (Madison Attallee #1) @NikiMackayBooks @LaurenBooksPR @orion_crime #I,Witness

April 16, 2018

Source: Review Copy

Publication:  19th April from Orion


They say I’m a murderer.

Six years ago, Kate Reynolds was found holding the body of her best friend; covered in blood, and clutching the knife that killed her.

I plead guilty.

Kate has been in prison ever since, but now her sentence is up. She is being released.

But the truth is, I didn’t do it.

There’s only one person who can help: Private Investigator Madison Attallee, the first officer on the scene all those years ago.

But uncovering the truth means catching a killer.


I really got caught up in I, Witness. For me it really was a one session read because once I had started I just didn’t want to stop. Most of that was due to the terrific protagonist, Madison Attallee, the perhaps archetypically troubled ex-cop, but my kind of woman. You know the one – she’s made some huge mistakes in her personal and professional life and now she’s working hard at getting her life back on track, but she can’t do that without a lot of nicotine which she hopefully imagines she can cover up with a liberal use of perfume and chewing gum. She doesn’t stop to eat, she’s hopelessly disorganised, a rock chic manqué and yet she used to be a great cop. Now, after a fall from grace, she is trying to build up a practice as a Private Investigator.

Into her office walks Kate Reynolds, newly released from prison, perhaps unwisely returned home to her stomping ground of Kingston, and starting to think, after pleading guilty to the manslaughter of her friend best Naomi and serving her sentence, that she might not be guilty after all.

Madison needs the work, but taking the case is more than that for her. She was the first officer at that murder scene. She remembers the state that Kate Reynolds was in, and something about the way Kate was treated and the absence of psychological care the traumatised girl should have had, did not sit well with the now ex-detective. That doesn’t mean she’s convinced of Kate’s innocence, but she’ll take the case.

Pretty much nobody wants Kate around. Her father, though providing financially for her, has not visited or spoken to her since the trial. Her brother communicated by letter once a month but is sure coming home is the wrong decision. Her sister is in a private healthcare facility and she has not heard from her or seen her in years and she won’t speak to her now. The parents of Naomi Andrews, the girl she pled guilty to killing, find it hard to take that she could be released after only six years and allowed to resume a life that is no longer available to their daughter.

Told in short chapters and using multiple voices this is a very well written story of lies, manipulation, and abuse. It is well plotted and some of the writing is so convincing as to be quite chilling, especially the relationship between Kate’s brother Marcus and his wife, Claudia.

The similarities between Kate and Madison make them well placed to form a tenuous relationship and it is clear that Kate’s isolation and vulnerability strikes a real chord with Madison; their relationship starts at a human level rather than simply professional and client.

I, Witness, has a well told, incisive and forceful plot that kept me captived and is utterly addictive. If I have a quibble, it’s only that the ending was a little too well tied up for me. I’d like to see more of the messed up Madison – and soon!

Amazon                              Waterstones

About Niki Mackay

niki mackay768x512

Niki studied Performing Arts at the BRIT School. It turned out that she wasn’t very good at acting but quite liked writing scripts. She went on to take a BA (Hons) in English Literature and Drama and later won a full scholarship for an MA in Journalism.

Niki loves words in many varied forms, and reads widely, but her first love is crime-fiction. She is interested in people and what makes them tick: class, prejudice, and feminism.

You can follow Niki on Twitter: @NikiMackayBooks

  1. Great review Mary! Quite interesting as well that she’s a private investigator now, I like the angle!


  2. Karen permalink

    Love your review, it sounds good


  3. jessiecahalin permalink

    It is difficult to chill the reader with the detail – sounds like powerful writing.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Teapot Tucker

A Book and a Brew Will See You Through


Lover of books and book reviewer. Usually found curled up with a book.

The Annual Bloggers Bash

The Official Website for the Best Blogging Event of the Year!

The Bibliofile

Book Reviews, Books, Bestsellers, Literary Fiction

Liz Loves Books

The Wonderful World of Reading

Daily (w)rite

Damyanti Biswas is an author, blogger, animal-lover, spiritualist. Her work is represented by Ed Wilson from the Johnson & Alcock agency. When not pottering about with her plants or her aquariums, you can find her nose deep in a book, or baking up a storm.

Being Anne...

Books, travel, and other things that make life interesting

Books in my Handbag Blog

"I love your book blog and am honoured to be there amongst such class" - Carol Drinkwater, Apr 2017

Short Book and Scribes

To the point book reviews and other bookish stuff

Bucks, Books & Beyond

This blog is for me to share with you where books have taken me recently.

Sandy's Book a Day Blog

A book a day is bliss😍

Over The Rainbow Book Blog

Book reviews and ramblings from a book mad mum of three!

Raven Crime Reads

Criminally good reads...


Live the life of a reader

A Knight's Reads

All things bookish

Barbara Copperthwaite



Fiction reviews, Bookblogger, Fiction book reviews, books, crime fiction, author interviews, mystery series, cover, love, bookish thoughts...

%d bloggers like this: